If you're thinking of Three Towns, those buffs are less than the crushing swings from the nerf bat that preceeded them....
Still, the point as posted sounds good to me. I don't want Shifters to suddenly turn into what PMs, Cleric Dragons or HIPSers have been in the past. But would like them to be more competitive at least. Epic versions of shapes need improving, at least. Other changes more complicated maybe. Undead forms for example. The Risen seems to be one of the few "almost okay" forms, and I have use a Vampire once or twice. But a Spectre? There are other combat machine shapes, so maybe give it some "specials"....
PS: Should this thread not be part of the "Shifter Classes" thread?